Overall, I can see that Kaya has a similar style as me. She takes pictures of things with a lot of color and also takes them up close. My favorite photos are the chalk, puppy, and the 6th one with her friend wearing lipstick. I like the chalk one because it has really cool texture and shows a lot of depth. The puppy one I like mainly because the puppy is really cute but also because I like how the blue tag stands out with its black fur. Finally, I like the one with her friend wearing lipstick because the bright red lipstick really stands out. I also like her facial expression, in that she looks very happy. The compositional elements I can see in her photos are: rule of thirds, texture, repetition with variety, value, and leading lines. I feel she does a very good job presenting all in these 15 photographs. The thing I feel she's missing in her portfolio is the lightning. Especially in the corn one, I feel it would be even cooler if it was shot outside on a sunny day and you can clearly see the definitions in it. I don't feel there's anything too repetitive because I feel she gives a good variety of photos that are mostly different from eachother. Overall, I feel these photos are great and I can tell she understands the compositions we learned in Photo One.